Stefanik: Compare Jobless Rates of States With Expanded Unemployment Benefits and States That Rescinded Those Benefits

By Susan Jones | June 10, 2021 | 8:34am EDT
A sign of the times in Annapolis, Maryland, as seen on May 12, 2021. (Photo by JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)
A sign of the times in Annapolis, Maryland, as seen on May 12, 2021. (Photo by JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)

( - Labor Secretary Marty Walsh on Wednesday defended Pandemic Unemployment Assistance -- an extra $300 a week in unemployment benefits passed by Congress as part of COVID-relief legislation.

The program runs through the week ending September 4, but already, more than half of the states have ended it early, saying it's contributing to a shortage of willing workers in businesses that are desperate to hire. That's because some people are earning more with the expanded unemployment benefits than they did at their pre-COVID jobs.

At a hearing of the House Education and Labor Committee on Wednesday, Walsh said, "I do not feel that the $300 bonus is keeping people out of work." Walsh said he thinks health concerns are keeping some people home and some industries closed. Walsh also mentioned "inefficiencies that we have to deal with," such as childcare and school closures.

Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) pointed to a recent report from the University of Chicago that says 42 percent of American workers are earning more through unemployment insurance than they are making in their pre-pandemic jobs. I'm hearing from small businesses and manufacturers all across my district and all across the country who are absolutely desperate to fill these vacant job openings."

Stefanik asked Walsh, "Are you going to collect data from the states to have wound down this federal unemployment assistance and compare it to states that have not, so we can truly see the impact of this federal unemployment assistance?"

"No state has done it yet," Walsh replied. "They've only--they've only mentioned it, but no one has actually...taken that action."

"Well, when they do that, will that data be collected?" Stefanik asked.

"I'm assuming--I--I--well, I can--I look at it and see if it is," Walsh said. "The unemployment extension runs out in September, so I'm not sure when they're going to take action on it."

"Great, so, that's not my question," Stefanik said. "My question is, will the department collect that data?"

"Of course. I--I said at the beginning of this I would look into it," Walsh said.

"Okay, great," Stefanik said. "So, I'll take that as a yes, that they will look into the data so we can see the comparison, because my bet, and you talk to any small businesses, I bet we're going to see much stronger job growth and states that wind down than in states that don't."

Earlier, Rep. Tim Walberg (R-Mich.) asked Walsh: "Given the plunge in COVID-19 cases, the unprecedented challenges businesses of all sizes are experiencing in my district, in many other places, is it time for this federal emergency employment insurance to be immediately terminated?"

"I can give you a simple answer to that -- no," Walsh said.

MRC Store