Alabama Governor Signs Law Banning Biological Males From Playing Girls' Sports

By Michael W. Chapman | April 26, 2021 | 11:22am EDT
Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey (R)   (Getty Images)
Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey (R) (Getty Images)

(CNS News) -- Alabama Governor Kay Ivey (R) signed legislation into law on Apr. 23 that prohibits transgender "females" (biological males) from joining real girls' sports teams, which will protect "biological female Athletes to compete on a fair playing field for scholarships and other athletic accomplishments," reads the new law.

The legislation, HB 391, was initially passed by the Alabama House (74-19) in March and then the Alabama Senate (25-5) on April 16.

Transgender "female" (biological male) athletes Andrea Yearwood and Terry Miller.  (Screenshot)
Transgender "female" (biological male) athletes Andrea Yearwood and Terry Miller. (Screenshot)

State Rep. Scott Stadthagen (R-Hartselle), who introduced the bill, said in February, “Basically, this bill — whatever your birth certificate says, if it says you are male or you are female, that is the sport you will play in K-12 athletics."

“I think this is more of a women’s rights [issue]," he added. "You know, this is something we definitely have to stay on top of. We have roughly about 16 other states that have filed legislation that is similar to this one. And I’m excited about it.”

Under the new law, at public K-12 schools, athletic events "allowing competition by one biological gender against another [are] prohibited unless the event specifically includes both genders."

Transgender "female" cyclist Rachel McKinnon, a biological male.  (Getty Images)
Transgender "female" cyclist Rachel McKinnon, a biological male. (Getty Images)

The law also declares the following, "Physical differences between biological males and biological females have long made separate and sex-specific sports teams important so that female athletes can have equal opportunities to compete in sports.

"Physical advantages for biological males relevant to sports include, on average, a larger body size with more skeletal muscle mass, a lower percentage of body fat, and greater maximal delivery of anaerobic and aerobic energy than biological females.

"... On average, biological male athletes are bigger, faster, stronger, and more physically powerful than their biological female counterparts. This results in a significant sports performance gap between the sexes.

Real girls, biological females, play field hockey.  (Getty Images)
Real girls, biological females, play field hockey. (Getty Images)

"... Testosterone suppression in biological males does not result in a level playing field between biological male and biological female athletes.

"Because of the physical differences between biological males and biological females, having separate athletic teams based on the athletes' biological sex reduces the chance of injury to biological female athletes and promotes sex equality. It provides opportunities for biological female athletes to compete against their peers rather than against biological male athletes, and allows biological female athletes to compete on a fair playing field for scholarships and other athletic accomplishments."

The states of Idaho, Mississippi, and Arkansas have laws on the books similar to the one in Alabama. 

"This bill is a shameful bill that is built on a web of lies and misinformation," said Carmarion D. Harvey-Anderson, the Alabama State Director of the pro-LGBTQ lobby group Human Rights Campaign. "Ultimately, HB 391 will not just hurt transgender kids. It will hurt all Alabamans because the consequences of this law — economic harm, expensive taxpayer-funded legal battles, and a tarnished reputation — will ripple across the state."

MRC Store